When Growth Outpaces Infrastructure: Access to Opportunities in Suburban Boomtowns
In the last twenty years, the population increased over 100% in Collin County, Texas. The county is projected to have over 2.4 million residents by 2050 -- more than three times its population in 2010. When enough people flock to an area to call it a boomtown, the population tends to grow much faster than the infrastructure to support it. Where does that leave mobility options for residents?
Researchers from the University of Texas at Arlington's (UTA) School of Social Work and College of Engineering partnered with the Collin County Homeless Coalition (CCHC) to investigate gaps in transportation services and infrastructure for lower-income individuals, particularly those experiencing houselessness or housing insecurity. They wanted to understand the impacts of those gaps on access to opportunities for environmental justice populations within North Central Texas.
Through funding from the National Institute for Transportation and Communities (NITC), researchers at UTA have already carved out a niche for themselves by forging new collaborations between transportation professionals and social workers, and this project builds on those efforts.
In this interdisciplinary study, led by Jandel Crutchfield of UTA, social workers engaged with the community to collect information about their experiences, and civil engineers worked to create statistical models based on that information. Together, they mapped census data onto transit use and transportation access.
Related Research: Check out "Examining the Feasibility of Shared Mobility Programs for Reducing Transportation Inequities: Perspectives from the Front-line (PDF)," a poster Kate Hyun presented at TRB with Sarah Robinson and Farah Naz of the University of Texas at Arlington.
The results offer an infrastructure profile for the region, in which increased infrastructure from tollways have improved job and population density, but with major challenges for usage of public transit. The results can inform public policies that support targeted investment and development of transit-supportive infrastructure, along with additional multimodal options.
Four focus groups were conducted with residents of Collin County, TX: two with environmental justice (EJ) and two with non-environmental justice (non-EJ) populations. Participants were asked about their experiences and perspectives of economic growth and transportation infrastructure in their county. Three themes emerged from those focus groups:
- Issues with existing public transit systems;
- Missing transportation infrastructure within communities;
- Problems faced by individual residents as a result of the current public transit system.
The final report (PDF) includes detailed discussion of these focus group results through the lens of the study's three primary research questions:
To what extent has transportation-infrastructure maintained pace with corresponding economic growth?
Overwhelmingly, both EJ and non-EJ participants felt that transportation infrastructure was severely lacking with respect to keeping pace with the economic boom.
How has this pace influenced residents’ access to housing, employment, healthcare, education, and social activities?
The pace of economic growth has resulted in extreme challenges with access to basic needs like healthcare, housing, employment, and education. The quantitative findings suggest that the majority of respondents use their own personal vehicles and believe the inconvenience of public transit and ride share options are too high to consider the transportation infrastructure effective. Those who are new to the county would be interested in using public transit and ride share options if they were more available.
How do perspectives differ between EJ and non-EJ residents?
Both EJ and non-EJ participants agreed that inconvenience is a deterrent from using public transit in the county, although those EJ populations without access to their own car were more negatively affected in access to healthcare, housing, employment, and education. For EJ participants, there was a preference for using public transportation if it were available, and low usage numbers are more a reflection of the lack of availability than preference.
In the quantitative portion of this study, the research team surveyed 205 residents (105 EJ population members and 100 non-EJ population members) to collect information about transportation behaviors, perceptions and barriers in Collin County.
- The age of the survey respondents ranged from 17 to 98, and the majority (23.41%) of the respondents were aged 35-44 years old.
- The majority of people self-identified as Caucasian (36.36%) followed by African American (24.75%), Hispanic (7.58%), and Asian (2.53%).
- Education level varied; the majority (26.83%) had a college degree, followed by 20.49% high school degree or equivalent and 17.07% with some college degree.
An overwhelming proportion of the respondents answered that they never took public transportation, used ride- or car-sharing systems, or biked. Walking was the only option that the respondents considered for daily use, other than a personal vehicle.
The majority of participants believed non-car transportation options (shared-ride service, public transit, and walking or biking) to be inconvenient. Many residents would like to use public transit if these barriers were not present.
Lastly, the study mapped transit patterns to analyze how transportation usage overlaps with socioeconomic status. Results indicated that as transportation infrastructure in the form of tollway roads increased, so did population density, job density, and percentage of minority population. These came with a corresponding decrease in poverty level.
To learn more about this study and its results, join us for a free webinar March 17, 2020 with Jandel Crutchfield and Kate Hyun of the University of Texas at Arlington.
This research was funded by the National Institute for Transportation and Communities and the National Science Foundation, with additional support from the University of Texas at Arlington and the Collin County Homeless Coalition.
To learn more about this and other NITC research, sign up for our monthly research newsletter.
- Access to Opportunities: Redefining Planning Methods and Measures for Disadvantaged Populations
- Developing Data, Models, and Tools to Enhance Transportation Equity
- Planning in Gateway and Amenity Communities: Understanding Unique Challenges Associated with Transportation, Mobility, and Access to Opportunity
The National Institute for Transportation and Communities (NITC) is one of seven U.S. Department of Transportation national university transportation centers. NITC is a program of the Transportation Research and Education Center (TREC) at Portland State University. This PSU-led research partnership also includes the Oregon Institute of Technology, University of Arizona, University of Oregon, University of Texas at Arlington and University of Utah. We pursue our theme — improving mobility of people and goods to build strong communities — through research, education and technology transfer.